December 24, 2015


City News Service 


A watchdog group critical of the Los Angeles Police Department’s gathering of data on suspicious activity sued the city of Los Angeles for the release of documents related to the program. Members of the Stop LAPD Spying Coalition, who have long pushed for the LAPD to dismantle its Suspicious Activity Reporting program, and their supporters said during a news conference outside police headquarters that they were forced to file the lawsuit after the city failed to provide adequate responses to two California Public Records Act requests submitted back in May. The coalition was joined in the lawsuit, which was filed in Los Angeles Superior Court, by the Los Angeles chapter of the National Lawyer’s Guild.


Colleen Flynn, the chapter’s interim executive director, alleged the LAPD “completely disregarded the statutory obligations” under public records laws. She said the public “has a right to documents that shed light on the LAPD's attempts to undermine constitutional protections in its overbroad data collection and sharing program.” Rob Wilcox, a spokesman for the City Attorney's Office, declined comment on the suit.


Members of the coalition and their supporters alleged that the city failed to give a response within 10 days of submitting the request, as required by state law, with city officials responding only after the group inquired about the request three months later. The city eventually responded by providing a description of the suspicious activity reporting program, but coalition members said they already had a copy of the same document. The city also said additional documents were being reviewed and there would be another response later, according to the coalition.


Another few weeks passed with no response, which prompted the coalition to send a letter to the city saying it planned to sue for the documents, according to the coalition. The coalition sought the documents to learn more about a program that they believe turns innocuous activity such as taking photos or recording video in public into criminally suspect behavior warranting secret reports to be kept by the LAPD. They say the department’s definitions of suspicious activity are too broad and may disproportionately target blacks and other minorities.


“With the filing of this lawsuit, we are saying enough to secrecy,” said Jamie Garcia, a member of the coalition. “We want to know what the full impact of the suspicious activity reporting initiative is on our community.”


Hamid Khan, a campaign coordinator with the coalition said, such reports are also frequently submitted by private citizens, which “leads us to believe is that they are actively promoting bias and prejudice.”


Khan said the request for the suspicious activity reports is “not something unusual.” The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Depart­ment complied with a similar request recently as the result of a lawsuit filed last year, so the city’s police department should not be able to site an exemption, according to Khan. Pete White of the Los Angeles Community Action Network, which is affiliated with the coalition, said the department failed to do the bare minimum that is required under the California Public Records Act.


“This isn’t as if there’s a lot of resources to file lawsuits against the city of L.A. that can (become) a protracted battle,” White said. “But it’s important that after seven months that they take us seriously, that they know they need to — at a minimum — follow the laws ... they tell us we need to follow.”

Category: News